7th Circuit Upholds Prison Ban of D&D
The nerds can't catch a break:
In an opinion issued on Monday, a three-judge panel of the Chicago-based Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals hexed a lawsuit challenging a ban on the game of Dungeons & Dragons by the Waupun Correctional Institution in Wisconsin.The Court determined that playing D&D could lead to enhanced gang behavior and violent escape attempts. This might be true for any actual gang members who were exposed to D&D nerds, but I doubt D&D would meaningfully contribute to this sort of behavior.
The suit was brought by a prisoner, Kevin T. Singer, who argued that his First Amendment and 14th Amendment rights were violated by the prison’s decision to ban the game and confiscate his books and other materials — including a 96-page handwritten manuscript he had created for the game.
Labels: 0L/1L Advice, Court Cases, Legal Issues
10 Comments:
Seems like a ridiculously overbearing approach to an even more ridiculous lawsuit. But the Volokh Conspiracy's question is interesting: could a prison ban The Count of Monte Cristo because it is likely to encourage escape attempts?
James, you just don't know how we roll in Wisconsin. A recent DOJ study found that 93% of prison violence at Waupan is related to D&D gangs.
Casey, you just rolled a 2 on your bluff check.
lol. McWho is 1337!
Heywood: "The Count of Monte Crisco, by Alexandre Dumbass. Dumbass! Ha ha!"
Andy: "Dumbass? Dumas. Ever read it? You'll like that one Heywood. It's about a jailbreak."
Red: "Jailbreak? Maybe we ought to file that one under 'educational' too?"
I'm guessing LARPing is also out as a prison activity in Wisconsin.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Darkon_Wargaming_Club
Years of law school, only to get a +2 expertise bonus to your litigation check.
Casey's pun is better than McWho's; it's earlier and more subtle. Round: Casey
As my name is also Casey, I will just say that I win anyway.
I'm going to apologize for zapping someone's comment without reading it. The poster's name looked like the typical spam stuff we get here. So I apologize, but strongly urge the adoption of a new moniker.
Post a Comment
<< Home